US Official caught trying to intimidate India over Union Carbide litigation
Mike Froman, U.S. Deputy National Security Adviser, was caught trying to force India to drop its legal case against Dow Chemical in his email last July to an Indian bureaucrat. In the email, he clearly links the Dow Chemical issue to relaxing India’s borrowing limit with the World Bank.
Using a traditional form of damage control, denial, Froman said that there was no connection intended between the two issues, although he did not explain why else he would mention the two subjects together. He explicitly states that the “Dow issue” would affect the “investment relationship” between the two countries. So, he doesn’t really leave any other way (or offer any other way) to possibly explain the email.
Dow Chemical owns Union Carbide, which has yet to face trial in India for operating an unsafe pesticide factory, resulting in the deaths of over 8,000 people in Bhopal on Dec 3 1984. Dow has tried to ignore the issue, but the case has become more high profile over the past few years in India.
His weak response has definitely not quieted the uproar over this release of information by “Times Now.” In fact, it has even shamed the famously inactive Indian government into publicly renewing its desire to extradite Union Carbides’ fugitive CEO, Warren Anderson, to India to face the homicide charges he has been dodging for over 25 years.
Bhopal residents have been very vocal in their search for clean water, land and justice for the crime, bringing international attention to the unresolved case. Their agitation has scared off several high profile Dow public events and even some foreign investment. The Indian government would prefer them to stay quiet and forget about 1984; they want foreign companies to know that environmental and legal standards will be lowered for them and they can operate without much official scrutiny. As Mike Froman noted, India’s message is mixed. This new leak will confuse it even more and threatens to change the way India promotes itself to US companies, chemical or otherwise.



